Welcome to H1BSupport.Com, please Ask a Question and an H1B Expert will provide an answer within 24 Hours!
Ask a question:

EB2 Case Study: RFE for Indian Chartered Accountancy Certificate OVERTURNED!

528 views 6 comments
posted Dec 12, 2016 in RFEs (H1B, I-140, PERM, Consulate) by Sheila Danzig (8,100 points)

One of the most common EB2 education RFEs arrives when a candidate holds a degree that doesn’t call itself a degree.  In fact Chartered Accountancy is the degree that receives the most RFEs for the EB2 classification.  Time and again, EB2 candidates who have earned an Indian Chartered Accountancy certificate receive an RFE even though it is the functional equivalent of a US Bachelor’s degree in accounting.

The EB2 visa requires a candidate to hold a US Master’s degree or its foreign equivalent or higher, OR a US bachelor’s degree or its foreign equivalent FOLLOWED BY at least five years of work experience in their current field of employ.  The RFE in this case arises when a candidate has an Indian Chartered Accountancy certificate and submits the petition without an accompanying credential evaluation that clearly spells out the steps of education required to earn this degree, and backs this up with international commerce and education decisions.

The AAO states in their 2007 decision:

“Passage of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) final examination and obtaining an associate membership in the ICAI is the foreign equivalent to a US bachelor’s degree in Accounting.”

In order to be eligible to even take this examination, a candidate must first pass the PE-II Intermediate examination.  The prerequisite to this examination is to have either completed an Indian bachelor’s degree or passed the PE-I.  Therefore, by following the steps of education required to be eligible to take, and to pass the ICAI final examination and earn the Indian Chartered Accountancy certificate, the candidate must have completed the functional equivalent of an Indian bachelor’s degree, and THEN taken and passed the ICAI final examination.

Yours or your employee or client client’s credential evaluation must clearly show these steps of education. 

Another reason this particular degree is so complicated is because both the Canadian Chartered Accountancy certification and the US CPA are NOT the functional equivalents of a US bachelor’s degree in accounting.  The Indian Chartered Accountancy certification carries the same name, but very different in terms of academic content.

If you or your employee or client has an Indian Chartered Accountancy certificate, do NOT submit the EB2 petition without a credential evaluation clearly explaining and justifying this degree’s functional equivalency to a US bachelor’s degree in Accounting.  If you or your employee or client received an RFE for his or her Indian Chartered Accountancy certificate, talk to a credential evaluation agency with experience working with EB2 RFEs and difficult degrees.

About the Author

Sheila Danzig

Sheila Danzig is the Executive Director at TheDegreePeople.com, a Foreign Credentials Evaluation Agency.  For a free analysis of any difficult case, RFE, Denial, or NOID, please go to http://ccifree.com/ or call 800.771.4723.


commented Dec 15, 2016 by anonymous

Any idea on the timeline when the sevis records will be updated for regular processing? Wolverine 3 logan jacket​ my grad advisor said it is not updated, does this mean my application is not picked?

replied Mar 27, 2017 by ukessaysreview.com/category/reviews/page
I guess that education is very important things if really want to achieve something good and have the best results. come in here <a href="http://ukessaysreview.com/category/reviews/page/2">ukessaysreview.com/category/reviews/page/2</a> and read .
replied Feb 27 by anonymous

Another reason this specific degree is so confounded is on the grounds that both the Canadian Chartered Accountancy affirmation and Coursework Help UK the US CPA are NOT the practical counterparts of a US four year college education in bookkeeping. The Indian Chartered Accountancy confirmation conveys a similar name, yet altogether different as far as scholarly substance.

commented Nov 30, 2017 by flipdiving (120 points)

Thanks for your sharing. Hope you can contribute more quality posts to this page. Thank you!

despacito lyrics

commented Apr 12 by anonymous
commented Apr 23 by hireitpeople (888 points)
This site is powered by http://www.hireitpeople.com All Articles are written and Questions are answered by H1B Experts at Hire IT People, Inc | If you are looking for a Project or an H1B Visa Transfer, with Immediate Green Card Process (From Day one) please call us at (800) 693-8939 or email at h1btransfer@hireitpeople.com. We are experts in handling Client letter matters, Specialty Occupation. | We provide excellent Employment Benefits and we work with Direct Clients |


H1B Employer, H1B Sponsor, H1B Transfer, h1b visa transfer,
H1B Sponsoring Companies, h1b visa consultants, companies sponsoring h1b visa, h1b attorney, h1b jobs, h1b visa employer

If you are looking for a Project or an H1B Visa Transfer, with Immediate GC Process, please call us at (800) 693-8939 or h1btransfer@hireitpeople.com